Abortion is the intentional termination of a pregnancy after conception. It allows women to put an end to their pregnancies, but involves killing the fetus or unborn child while the child is still in the mother’s womb. For this reason, it is a very controversial subject.
Abortion is a very controversial subject that has been continually argued over for a very long time. Due to the severity of the consequences of an abortion and the moral and religious elements involved, this is an ethical controversy and has divided people for decades. The main controversy is should abortion be legalised? For many people, abortion is sought to be rather disturbing, unethical, and immoral, as Mahatma Gandhi says: "It seems to be clear as daylight that abortion would be a crime." (http://www.angelfire.com/mo/baha/ghandi.html). However, abortion can be legalised but only under a case to case examination, like for instance, for rape and incest victims and women who are in life-threatening situations. In such situations, we cannot deny that to be able to choose a safe, legal abortion makes many other options possible. Otherwise an accident or a rape can end a woman's economic and personal freedom.
That is why, there is the need to make a distinction between abortion for convenience sake, and abortion for medical reasons, as well as abortion in the limited cases of rape/incest.
It is true that a woman has a right to her own body. However, the fetus, or unborn baby, is a distinct individual. Even though it resides inside its mother, it is a separate entity genetically. From the moment of conception, it is an entirely separate genetic individual. Therefore, the argument in favour of abortion on demand, or abortion for convenience sake, that a woman has a right to do as she wishes to her own body, is not applicable to the question of abortion, since the mother's body is different from that of her baby, or fetus.
The health threat to the mother after going through with the procedure as well as the lifelong health risks that remain should be good enough reasons abortion should be illegal.
Abortion affects society, families, and the individuals who allow the procedure to be done. It also teaches people that there is a way out of pregnancy and that is also why it is important not to legalise abortion.
Abortion affects society by teaching the youth that there is a way out of pregnancy. What should really be taught to the youth is abstinence from sex at a too early age or have safe sex and to be responsible of their acts, so that they would never have to worry about experiencing an unwanted pregnancy. It also teaches the youth that there is no serious consequence for that major action since abortion is the way out and the ready-made solution to pregnancy, if ever there is one.
Abortion is never an easy decision, but women have been making that choice for thousands of years. Whenever a society has sought to outlaw abortions, it has only driven them into back alleys, where they became dangerous, expensive and humiliating. That is why many proponents for the legalisation of abortion are adamant in their statement that laws against abortion kill women. They argue that to prohibit abortions does not stop them. When women feel it is absolutely necessary, they will choose to have abortions--even in secret, without medical care, in dangerous circumstances. In the two decades before abortion was legal in the U.S. , it has been estimated that nearly 1 million women per year sought out illegal abortions. Thousands died. Tens of thousands were mutilated (http://www.rtl.org/prolife_issues/abortionstats_us.html). All were forced to behave as if they were criminals.
Should the penalty for lack of knowledge or even for a moment's carelessness be enforced pregnancy and child-rearing? Or dangerous illegal abortion? Should we consign a teenager to a life sentence of joblessness, hopelessness and dependency? These are the other set of arguments that people in favour of abortion put forth to convince people and authorities about the need to leaglise abortion.
Should the penalty for lack of knowledge or even for a moment's carelessness be enforced pregnancy and child-rearing? Or dangerous illegal abortion? Should we consign a teenager to a life sentence of joblessness, hopelessness and dependency? These are the other set of arguments that people in favour of abortion put forth to convince people and authorities about the need to leaglise abortion.
If women are forced to carry unwanted pregnancies to term, the result is unwanted children. It has been proven that many such children, when they grow up, are often seriously disadvantaged, and sometimes inclined to brutal behaviour toward others. This is not good for children, for families or for the country. Children need love and families who want and will care for them
Choice therefore should not be an option for families; it should be their right. Even when precautions are taken, accidents can and do happen. For some families, this is not a problem.
But for others, such an event can be catastrophic. An unintended pregnancy can increase tensions, disrupt stability and push people below the line of economic survival. Family planning is the answer. All options must be open. At the most basic level, the proponents firmly advocate that the abortion issue is not really about abortion. It is about the value of women in society. Should women make their own decisions about family, career and how to live their lives? Or should government do that for them? Do women have the option of deciding when or whether to have children? Or is that a government decision? But perhaps the question that we should ask ourselves first is whether abortion would make those families less poor?
Choice therefore should not be an option for families; it should be their right. Even when precautions are taken, accidents can and do happen. For some families, this is not a problem.
But for others, such an event can be catastrophic. An unintended pregnancy can increase tensions, disrupt stability and push people below the line of economic survival. Family planning is the answer. All options must be open. At the most basic level, the proponents firmly advocate that the abortion issue is not really about abortion. It is about the value of women in society. Should women make their own decisions about family, career and how to live their lives? Or should government do that for them? Do women have the option of deciding when or whether to have children? Or is that a government decision? But perhaps the question that we should ask ourselves first is whether abortion would make those families less poor?
Even for feminists, rather than liberating women, abortion liberated men from obligations to their partners and children. Child abuse and the feminisation of poverty have escalated since the availability of abortion, and instead of shared responsibility, more of the burden of child rearing has shifted to women. “By giving in to abortion instead of working for social changes that would facilitate combining children and career, we have relieved society of its obligation to accommodate the real needs of women” (http://www.euthanasia.com/femin.html).
I firmly believe that abortion should be legalised in cases of rape and incest so that victims would not have to live and be constantly reminded of their trauma; and in cases where the life of the mother is threatened. In other cases, abortion is getting more and more often used as a method of birth control. They are being placed in the same category as the birth control pill. If abortion remains so accessible or becomes authorised, people will not consider unsafe sex practices as serious as they ought to. Couples may approve unprotected sex for the reason that if the woman becomes pregnant, then she could, at any time, just get an abortion. Abortion seems like and uncomplicated way out of an extremely complex problem. If people are old enough to have sex, they should also be mature enough to be responsible and to nurture the practice of protected and safe sex. This is in fact what George W Bush said in the Speech to Republican National Convention Aug 3, 2000: “I will lead our nation toward a culture that values life -- the life of the elderly and the sick, the life of the young, and the life of the unborn. I know good people disagree on this issue, but surely we can agree on ways to value life by promoting adoption and parental notification, and when Congress sends me a bill against partial-birth abortion, I will sign it into law….except in cases of rape, incest or to save the mother’s life…….” http://www.ontheissues.org/George_W__Bush_Abortion.htm
Very nice topic :)
ReplyDeleteNormally abortion is done within 4 weeks and at that time the heart is not beating yet. (Correct me if am wrong).
Well, my personal view is that you cannot force a rape victim to bear the child of a criminal. It's like raping the woman over and over again each time she sees the kid. Now there are cases where the mother loves the child and forgets about the origins.
There is the moral and the personal point of view which seems to clash. But then, instead of giving birth to an unwanted child, abusing it and all, rather not have it...
Yes, I would be for legal abortion.
That's my point of view...
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI think that a person’s position on abortion would a combination of their personal beliefs on the morality of induced abortion and their beliefs on the ethical limit of the government's legitimate authority.
ReplyDeleteAs mentioned in your article there are two major camps, with people in favor of legal abortion and those against legal abortion. In reality, the two camps are too simplistic to encompass the full complexity of the debate. A person may be personally uncomfortable with, and morally opposed to, abortion while believing the option of abortion should remain legal. Furthermore, individuals often place different value on the lives of zygotes, embryos and foetuses at different points in gestation, putting different methods of abortion in different moral lights. That why one aspect of the issue involves defining at what point an embryo or fetus qualifies as a person, and gains the legal and/or moral right to life.
As you correctly mentioned, the debate indeed touches upon such related and controversial issues as contraception, feminism, gender roles, teen pregnancy, and sexual morality. The argument for abortion for an assault rape pregnancy continues and remains approved by two-thirds of the population worldwide. The answer here may be education, pointing out that there are only hundred of such pregnancies a year for example in the whole US and that only half of these women seek abortion, and that her chief complaint is not being pregnant but how others treat her. Here the central answer of course is that we oppose killing an innocent baby for the crime of his father. Sadly, politicians continue to put this exception in law.
Underlying this debate is another debate, over the proper role of the state: to what extent should a government be allowed to interfere with a woman's reproduction? This is a major issue in a number of countries, such as India and China, which have tried to enforce types of birth control (including forced sterilization), and it also has a prominent place in political campaigning in many countries for example in the United States, the Democratic Party tends to campaign in support of the legal right to an abortion, while the Republican Party tends to campaign against legal abortion.
I think we have to look for alternatives to abortion: Is adoption a viable and fair alternative to abortion? Are there resources available to aid mothers who are unprepared for parenthood, but who may wish to keep their child? And what are the limits of government authority: Are laws controlling abortion violations of privacy and/or other personal liberty rights?
Nice cmap as summary for the issue..
Fardeen khan..
Your topic has been very well illustrated. It is true that victims of rape and incest cannot be forced to face a child born out of lust and disgust instead of love and marriage!
ReplyDeleteHowever, abortion is not fully accepted from a religious point of view. We do not have the right to end a life, which is yet to start, to live fully, to be surrounded by parents... That unborn child is not guilty, he is not aware about rape, early sex or unsafe sex...for him, he has a mother and a father and he only wishes to be next to both...
As Fardeen stated, why not find alternatives such a adoption. It is better to make sterile couples happy parents instead of committing a murder...
According to my point of view, i am against abortion...we are responsible adults, and having sex is not a game. Neither terminating the life of an innocent nor having abortion as an alternative solution to one moment of carelessness, is the final solution...
Gopaul mardaymootoo:
ReplyDeleteI think this is a very delicate issue. Situations where the legalisation of abortion is justified are as follows:
1. To save the life of the mother in case of complications.
2. To preserve the physical and mental health of the mother.
3. In cases of rape and incest.
4. When the foetus has medical problems or defects.
5. For social reasons e.g. if the mother is unmarried and lives in an orthodox society.
6. For economics reasons, e.g. if the mother cannot afford to support a child.
Many developed countries such as Australia, Belgium, Canada, China, Germany, Netherlands and United States have completely legalised abortion based on above factors. (http://www.pregnantpause.org/lex/world02.htm).
On the other hand, abortion is unethical as it involves taking the life of an individual, even though it is still on its way of formation. Religious views are strongly against this practice as one cannot take the life of someone if he does not have the capacity to give life. Furthermore, there might be side effects which may be prevent the mother from conceiving again. This practice is even more dangerous when it is performed in clandestine abortion clinics or by unequipped abortion practitioners.
As you mentioned, the cases where abortion should be legalised are justified. In Mauritius, we have to overcome a lot of barriers in order to legalise abortion. I also agree with you for the preventive measures to control child birth rather than abortion.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteTolsy Pillai
ReplyDeleteI think abortion is wrong. It is an issue of concern to whole network of people from common man to businessman. Abortion is an issue that goes beyond faith and into simple ethics and morality. Many social networking sites for e.g like http://www.nationalblackprolifeunion.com/
•provide a debate on abortion and also provide
•enable people to vote for and against
•Enable people to share their opinion on same
Laws have never stopped abortion, but only made it unsafe for women. Abortion is a universal practice that has been with us since the beginning of time, whether legal or illegal. Laws have never stopped abortion, but only made it unsafe for women. A social networking site like Exhale (talkline) was created by and for women who have abortions. The site offers a free, After-Abortion Talkline that provides emotional support, resources and information for women and girls who have had abortions and to their partners, friends, allies and family members. Thousands of women from different culture from different countries exchange their problems and have moral support from counsellers who are unknown to them.
Supporters and opponents of abortion rights are using social networking tools -- such as blogs, text messaging, Facebook and Twitter -- to rally grassroots support and keep their constituencies informed about abortion provisions in congressional health reform legislation.